data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6a6d1/6a6d175947d71d4b191e9e4d6d397b66c6b05912" alt=""
The danger of legalism in church is real in large part because legalistic lies sound so correct. On the surface, they make a lot of sense . . . until they are scrutinized under the authority of God's Word. By the light of Scripture, many a right-sounding-lie has been exposed for what it is.
There is one legalistic teaching that echos through the walls of the modern church every week in a multitude of churches. The fallacy of the statement is so subtle that even a seasoned grace walker might easily miss it. I contend that the statement is legalistic, in the sense that it is grounded in Old Testament Law. What is this statement that pulls so many unsuspecting Christians into its snare? It is this:
You should love God more. "Wait a minute!" you may protest. "How can it possibly be said that to say we should love God more is legalistic? We
should love God more!"
Hold on for a moment. I ask you to calm whatever emotional knee-jerk reaction you might feel right now and consider, not what you feel or have always thought, but instead consider what the Bible says. Can we agree that the Bible has the final word on the matter?
One time some Pharisees (the legalists of His day) came to Jesus. Matthew 22 says,
One of them, a lawyer, asked Him a question, testing Him, 36 "Teacher, which is the great commandment in the Law?" 37 And He said to him, " `YOU SHALL LOVE THE LORD YOUR GOD WITH ALL YOUR HEART, AND WITH ALL YOUR SOUL, AND WITH ALL YOUR MIND.' 38 "This is the great and foremost commandment. 39 "The second is like it, `YOU SHALL LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOR AS YOURSELF.' 40 "On these two commandments depend the whole Law and the Prophets.Look at the question asked of Jesus: What is the greatest Law? What was the answer Jesus gave? "You shall love the Lord." The reason, then, why I insist that to teach that we must love the Lord is legalistic is because Jesus, Himself, said it is the greatest of the Laws.
What does the Law do in a person's life? Paul said in Romans 7:5 that it "stirs up sinful passions." In other words, it provokes the opposite response from what it tells us to do. He gives an example by pointing out that coveting wasn't a problem for him until he learned that the Law says "Don't covet." Suddenly, he found himself coveting like crazy. (Read it for yourself in Romans 7:7-8)
So the Law, then, works like reverse psychology. It motivates you to do the exact opposite of what it tells you. So what happens to people when they are told that they
should (There's the definitive word.) love God. Just the opposite arises within them. That's why so many Christians are literally praying for God to help them to love Him more. It's because they are experiencing the predictable outcome of trying to live up to the Law, "Thou shalt love the Lord thy God."
What is the answer of grace to this dilemma? It is to teach people how much the Lord their God loves them! 1 John 4:19 says, "We love because He first loved us." There's the answer. To love Him more we only need to understand how much He loves us! As we grow in the understanding of His unlimited, unconditional love, our response will be to love Him!
Every week Christians are being told in churches all over the world that they should love God more. That kind of teaching will never yield the fruit we want. On the other hand, if they are clearly taught the Father's love for them, you can't stop them from growing in love for Him.
It sounds good, on the surface, to say that we ought to love God more. The question is "How?" The answer to loving Him more isn't to be taught the greatest Law ever given. We don't live under the Law anymore. The answer is to be told the good news that He loves us. That's New Covenant teaching. The subtlety of the Law that teaches we should love Him more is keeping people under the curse of guilt and condemnation for not succeeding in that area. Let's embrace grace and share it with others. The Lord your God loves you! That fact is the only thing that can produce genuine love in us.
What do you think?